- Leadership Unscripted
- Posts
- Your Employee Isn’t Failing. Your System Might Be.
Your Employee Isn’t Failing. Your System Might Be.
Performance issues often point somewhere else. Here’s where to look.
A Conversation We’re Hosting
We’re bringing together a small group of HR leaders in San Francisco on April 23 for a breakfast in collaboration with TroopHR and Plenty Search.
Right now, many teams are navigating the same question in different ways. How AI is reshaping how we work, how we lead, and how we think about talent.
This won’t be a presentation. It’s a working conversation.
What’s actually changing inside your organization?
What’s working? What’s not?
What are leaders being asked to hold right now?
We’re finding that in moments like this, community becomes one of the most valuable inputs.
If you’re based in San Francisco (or have a team member in the Bay Area) and part of a seated HR leadership team, we’d value having you in the room.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Happy Wednesday!
Welcome to Leadership Unscripted. Each edition, we share 1 Case Study, 1 Framework, 1 Question. These are real moments and practical strategies for rethinking your approach to leadership.
Let’s dive in.
1 Case Study
Maria was leading a growing team inside a professional services firm. The work was complex (just like at your company), deadlines were tight, and expectations were high. One of her team members had started to slip.
Missed details. Slower turnaround. A noticeable drop in consistency.
At first, it looked like an individual performance issue. Maria addressed it directly. She clarified expectations, gave specific feedback, and reinforced what needed to improve.
The performance didn’t change.
Over the next few weeks, the pattern widened. Work required closer review. Timelines compressed around that role. Other team members quietly adjusted to compensate, pulling attention away from their own priorities and slowing overall delivery.
It was no longer isolated.
In a coaching conversation, Maria walked through the situation. Her examples were clear. Her conclusion felt reasonable.
The employee was underperforming.
Then the questions shifted.
What has changed in their role over the last 60 days?
How often are priorities shifting without being fully reset?
When does this person actually receive feedback relative to the work?
She paused.
The role had expanded, quietly.
Priorities had moved, often.
Feedback was happening, just later than it needed to.
The performance issue was real. The conditions around it had not been examined.
Maria changed the system.
Expectations were clarified earlier in the work cycle. Priorities stabilized across the week. Feedback moved closer to the moment it mattered.
The shift was not immediate. Then it was visible.
The same employee began delivering with clarity and consistency. The team stopped compensating. Work flowed without added friction.
Because performance responds to the system around it.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
When performance drops, the instinct is to look at the person. The more effective move is to examine the environment that the person is operating within.
1 Framework
The System Check
This is a pattern we see across teams, industries, and leadership levels.
Before labeling performance, evaluate the conditions around it:
Expectations: Are they clear, current, and reinforced early enough to guide the work?
Feedback: Is it happening in time to influence the next outcome?
Priorities: Are they stable, or shifting without full reset?
Accountability: Is ownership clear, or does it default back to the leader?
If any of these are unclear, performance will follow.
This is not about lowering the bar. It is about making the bar visible and reachable.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1 Question
The culture and leadership behavior of others matter. 👉 What part of your environment is shaping the results you are seeing?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The Leadership Work Behind Performance
This is where leadership becomes visible.
Leaders are often taught how to evaluate performance. Far fewer are taught how to shape the conditions that drive it. The difference shows up quickly in growing teams, where complexity increases faster than clarity and small gaps compound into missed expectations, slower delivery, and unnecessary rework.
If you are seeing:
Inconsistent execution across your team
Feedback that lands after the work instead of during it
Priorities shifting faster than they are understood
you are not looking at isolated performance issues. You are looking at a system that is producing exactly what it is set up to produce.
The work of leadership is to change that system.
The Arrive. Leadership Academy is built for this shift.
Across four sessions, leaders build the capability to:
Set and reinforce expectations in real time
Deliver feedback that changes the next outcome, not the last one
Stabilize priorities in dynamic environments
Create accountability that is shared and sustained
April cohorts are now open.
If you are investing in your next layer of leaders, or stepping more fully into that responsibility yourself, this is where the shift becomes tangible.
Because performance is not only a reflection of the individual.
It is a reflection of how leadership is showing up around them.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Real Stories. Real Tools. Real Impact.
Forget the fluff. We’re that company, revealing behind-the-scenes leadership wins and strategies that actually work.
Because all it takes is one bold move to shatter barriers, inspire your team, and make your mark.
We believe in feedback cultures. What did you think of this week's issue?We take your feedback seriously. |
